Journal

Winter 97-98 Issue

 

The Wildlands Project: No longer a Dream

When the Wildlands Project was released by the radical environmentalists in 1992, most Americans ignored the effort believing it was both ridiculous and impossible. The environmentalists’ plan to "re-wild" the North American continent, forcing the entire human population to evacuate their homes and live in small, confined colonies while animals run wild over most of the continent, was never taken seriously by landowners. Today, we see the plan coming together all around us, through Presidential Executive Order, federal agency action, legislation, and environmental activism. This article traces the patterns and progress made by environmentalists to implement the Wildlands Project. It is a condensed version from the "Technical Review of the Wildlands Project" written by Tom McDonald.

During the past several years, resource industries, state and local governments and communities nationwide have been buried under an avalanche of new species listings, appeals and litigation to stop development, water usage, logging, mining, grazing and recreational activities.

There have been vast amounts of legislation proposing new wilderness areas, heritage areas, scenic rivers, biological corridors, state and national parks or wildlife refuges, as well as management plans involving critical habitat, watersheds or ecosystems.

While many of these actions seem to be isolated incidents, a review of the Wildlands Project suggests that the actions are often well coordinated activities aimed, according to the Project’s text, at establishing a "regional reserve system which will ultimately tie the North American continent into a single Biodiversity Reserve."

To date, over 35 various environmental groups have been identified as members of the Project. These groups have petitioned for over 100 species to be listed as threatened or endangered suggesting that they are using the Endangered Species Act to promote political and social agendas rather than for conservation of truly threatened species.

Former Earth First! member and founder, Dave Foreman introduced the concept of the Wildlands Project in his book Confessions of an Eco-Warrior. In the introduction to the Wildlands Project, Foreman states "Our vision is continental...we seek to bring together conservationists, ecologists, indigenous peoples, and others to protect and restore evolutionary processes and biodiversity."

He called for "reserves established to protect wildlife habitat, biodiversity, ecological integrity, ecological service and evolutionary processes — that is vast interconnected areas of true wilderness." And described wilderness as the "home for unfettered life, free from industrial human intervention" with "extensive areas of native vegetation in various successional stages, off-limits to human exploitation" that includes "vast landscapes without roads, dams, motorized vehicles, power lines, over flights, or other artifacts of civilization." Over half the North American land mass is envisioned as making up this massive wilderness reserve system.

The Project calls on the establishment of systems of core wilderness areas, where human activity is prohibited, linked with biological corridors. Around these core reserve areas and their interlinking corridors, buffers are to be established. The buffer areas are to be managed to restore ecological health. All human activity associated with civilization — agriculture, industrial production, urban centers — will only be allowed to continue outside these buffered regions.

The central office of the Wildlands Project is located in Tucson, Arizona and serves as a clearinghouse and coordination point for implementing the project. Funds for the project are obtained through solicitations, advertisements and from grant-makers. It has public relations, publishing and research capabilities.

Member groups first recruit other activists, professional ecologists, sympathetic government agency personnel and others to assist in the development of proposals for the Wilderness Recovery Network at the regional and ecosystem level. Trust groups such as The Nature Conservancy are plugged into the proposals so that when gaps are identified within their reserve network, these areas can become priorities for land acquisition.

To determine the location of the wilderness areas all currently protected areas were identified and laid out on a map. Then "Big Outside Areas," or roadless areas, defined as areas of 100,000 or more acres in the West and 50,000 or more acres in the East, were overlaid on the map. These roadless areas may include state, federal, as well as, private land.

The Wildlands Project’s central Tucson office has at least 385 maps of large roadless areas available and has been working on the development of more detailed state maps to assist regional groups in their work.

The protected areas such as wildernesses and National Parks within the Big Outside (roadless) areas are identified as key core areas. Protected areas outside identified roadless areas are examined to see if they can "serve as beads in Biological Corridors linking Core Wilderness together."

Identified roadless areas that are not already protected with National Park, wilderness or other similar designations, are considered unprotected and given the highest priority for conservation. Unprotected roadless areas which are federal and state lands are targeted for future wilderness bills, heritage sites or other protective legislation. Private lands within these areas are given the highest priority for public agency or trust group acquisition.

Besides legislation and acquisition, these maps establish the priorities for appeals and litigation. As stated within Wildlands documents, "It is usually more important ... to stop an old-growth timber sale within a Big Outside area or in a corridor between two core areas than to stop an old-growth sale in a fragmented area far from potential cores or corridors. It is usually more important to establish a Wilderness Area that is part of a large complex, than one isolated in a matrix of intensive human use."

By 1994, the Wildlands Project had identified 38 areas in the western United States where minor road closures would create large roadless areas of more than a million acres. In total, these areas make up more that 75 million acres.

Once the core reserve areas (including currently protected lands and roadless areas) have been established, all USFS, BLM, state forest, military and other types of state, federal and local lands are to be examined for potential addition to the core reserve lands or to buffer areas. Gaps between core reserve areas have been identified, and the private lands that can serve as corridors to link these reserve areas have been targeted for acquisition by government and trust groups. As stated in the documents, this will be "especially crucial in the east."

Once all the core wilderness areas, with their corridors and buffer zones are established at a regional basis, they will be linked to other regional systems, until the entire North American continent is converted into a large interconnected bioreserve.

Until all federal lands can be examined for inclusion into the reserve system, Wildlands documents state the following about their management:

"One hundred years ago, John Muir argued that the newly withdrawn Forest Reserves in the West should be protected from logging, mining and livestock grazing. A key part of the American Wilderness Recovery Plan is to return to Muir’s vision for management of our public lands. Commercial livestock grazing of federal and state lands cannot be justified ecologically or economically. Commercial logging, with the possible exception of small pole, post, and firewood sales, should be prohibited. Mining is an inappropriate use of public lands in virtually all cases. Vehicle use off established roads must be entirely prohibited. By freeing Forest Service, BLM, and state lands of such multiple-abuses, many roads and other developments could be closed. Roads necessary only for logging and grazing or recreational access should be closed. It may be necessary to allow some roads to remain open to official use for short time periods to allow active restoration in severely abused areas, or for reintroduction of extirpated species, but the majority of dirt and gravel roads on the public lands should be closed quickly."

Large predators are a central focus to the Wildlands Project. The Project especially keys to large wide-ranging predators like the grizzly and black bear, wolves, cougars, jaguars and lynx. In recent years, many of these groups have been involved in efforts to provide additional federal protection and recovery to grizzlies, jaguars and wolves.

Regarding the rest of the native plants and animals, Wildlands Project documents state that "perhaps 90 percent of the rest of biodiversity will also be protected." Members of the Wildlands Project have petitioned for the listing of over 100 species as threatened or endangered and have filed lawsuits for the listing of over 2,000 species.

Members of the Wildlands Project have been very active in litigating the shut down of livestock grazing, mining and timber activities. On March 3, 1995, 11 of the 35 known member groups had suits filed against the Department of Interior, Environmental Protection Agency or U.S. Department of Agriculture. Thirty-nine separate suits were filed by these 11 organizations.

One of the more aggressive organizations in the filing of citizen suits has been the Oregon Natural Resources Council. In March 1995, this organization had 16 active citizen suits regarding the Clean Water Act, Clean Air Act, Endangered Species Act and NEPA.

Many of the appeals, listings of threatened and endangered species, litigation, legislation, regulations and management plans at the state and federal level have been analyzed by natural resource industries as separate issues. After reviewing the Wildlands Project, its associated member groups, and the issues which they have been involved in the last four years, it becomes evident that many of the issues once thought to be independent cases are, in actuality, interrelated issues. To understand the foundation and logic for many of the issues we face today, one must understand the concepts and structure of the Wildlands Project.

Tom McDonald is the executive director of the American Sheep Industry Association.

The Wildlands Project identified 38 areas in the West where minor road closures would create large roadless areas for a combined total of 75 million acres closed to human access. These include:

North Cascades - Washington (3 million acres)

Olympia Mountains - Washington (1.2 million acres)

Kalmiopsis/Siskiyous/Trinity Alps - Oregon, California (2 million acres)

Hells Canyon/Eagle Cap - Oregon, Idaho (1.5 million acres)

Selway-Bitterroot/River of No Return - Idaho, Montana (5.5 million acres)

Great Rift - Idaho (1 million acres)

Owyhee - Idaho, Oregon, Nevada (8 million acres)

Oregon Desert - Oregon, Nevada (3 million acres)

Bob Marshall - Montana (3 million acres)

Beartooth - Montana, Wyoming (1.5 million acres)

North Absaroka - Wyoming (1 million acres)

Upper Yellowstone/South Absaroka - Wyoming (2.5 million acres)

Tetons/SW Yellowstone - Wyoming, Idaho (1 million acres)

Wind Rivers - Wyoming (1.2 million acres)

Red Desert - Wyoming (1 million acres)

Maroon Bells - Colorado (1 million acres)

San Juan Mountains - Colorado (2 million acres)

Desolation Canyon - Utah (2.2 million acres)

High Uintas - Utah (1 million acres)

Canyonlands - Utah (3 million acres)

San Rafael/Wayne Wonderland - Utah (1 million acres)

Escalante/Kaiparowits/Henry Mts. - Utah (3 million acres)

Desert Game Range - Nevada (1.5 million acres)

Black Rock Desert - Nevada (2.5 million acres)

Smoke Creek Desert - Nevada, California (1 million acres)

High Sierra - California (3 million acres)

Yosemite North - California (1 million acres)

Los Padres - California (2 million acres)

Death Valley/Inyo - California (1.5 million acres)

Panamint Mountains (Death Valley West) - California (1.5 million acres)

Mojave Desert - California (1.5 million acres)

Bill Williams River - Arizona (1 million acres)

Kofa - Arizona (1.5 million acres)

Cabeza Prieta - Arizona (2 million acres)

Galiuro/Pinleno - Arizona (1 million acres)

Grand Canyon/Kaibab - Arizona (3 million acres)

Gila/Black Range - New Mexico (1.5 million acres)

Guadalupe Escarpment - New Mexico, Texas (1 million acres)

The Wildlands Project has over 35 known activist groups now working on implementing the Project at the regional and ecosystem level. Some of the known members include:

Alaska: Southeast Alaska Conservation Council

Arizona: Sky Island Alliance, Sororan Arthropod Studies Inc., Predator Damage Review

California: California Wilderness Coalition, Klamath Forest Alliance, Planet Drum Foundation

Colorado: Biodiversity Legal Foundation

Idaho: Idaho Conservation League

Indiana: Heartwood

Montana: Alliance for the Wild Rockies

New Mexico: Forest Guardians, Gila Watch, Lighthawk, Public Lands Action Network

New York: Finger Lakes Wild!

Oregon: Coast Range Association, Hells Canyon Preservation Council, Native Forest Council, Oregon Natural Desert Association, Oregon Natural Resources Council, Rest The West, Siskiyou Regional Education Project, The Xerces Society

Texas: Environmental Ethics, Forest Reform Network

Utah: Great Old Broads For Wilderness

Vermont: Preserve Appalachian Wilderness

Virginia: Virginians for Wilderness

Washington: Greater Ecosystems Alliance

Washington D.C.: Save America’s Forests

Wisconsin: Society for Ecological Restoration, Superior Wilderness Action Network

Wyoming: Friends of the Bow (renamed Biodiversity Associates)

British Columbia, Canada: Thatshenshini Wild