CHICO, Calif. -"Meat is murder," activists from the
Animal Liberation Front scrawled on a McDonald's restaurant here last
month.
Two crude incendiary devices failed to ignite,
but a second McDonald's in this Sacramento Valley college town was damaged
a week later by burning debris. A day later, two Albuquerque, N.M.,
McDonald's and an Arby's were firebombed, with police suggesting similar
ties to the nation's most active, destructive domestic
terrorists.
The Golden Arches have been hit abroad as a
symbol of the United States' corporate dominance and encroaching
lifestyle. But the fire bombings of the ubiquitous hamburger restaurants
at home have hit a jarring note with company officials and law enforcement
nationwide.
An Earth Liberation Front promotional video
called "Igniting the Revolution" features McDonald's among its corporate
targets. The FBI labels the elusive, loosely knit shadow organizations the
nation's most active and destructive domestic terror groups, responsible
for more than $43 million in damage in more than 600 attacks since
1996.
"They're going after the wrong people, because
we have an exemplary record when it comes to animal welfare," said
McDonald's Corp. spokeswoman Lisa Howard.
McDonald's launched a public relations effort
in response, erecting racks of brochures at its restaurants and
information on its Web site touting its social and environmental
stewardship.
That's not good enough for ALF and ELF, said
Rodney Coronado, a former ALF member who spent more than four years in
prison for a 1992 fire bombing of animal research laboratories at Michigan
State University.
"Wherever they are, McDonald's are a
legitimate target for people who want to protect the earth," Coronado
said. "McDonald's is a symbol of international animal abuse and
environmental destruction."
Coronado demonstrated a device similar to that
used in the Chico attack at a January conference at Washington, D.C.'s
American University. Directions on building the devices also are on ALF's
and ELF's Web sites, enabling activists to encourage copycat arsons
without having direct knowledge of the crimes.
"It's a way we can insulate ourselves -
there's no signature device. It's a crude, inexpensive device that can be
very effective," Coronado said, though the ones in Chico
fizzled.
Ron Arnold of the Center for the Defense of
Free Enterprise in Bellevue, Wash., said the elusive attacks leave
McDonald's Corp. in a state of denial as it juggles more than 30,000
restaurants in 118 countries serving 46 million customers a
day.
It downplays attacks for fear of frightening
customers and shareholders, said Arnold, author of "EcoTerror: The Violent
Agenda to Save Nature-the World of the Unabomber."
David Martosko, research director for the
Washington, D.C.-based Center for Consumer Freedom, said McDonald's
attacks that get publicity are "literally the tip of the
iceberg."
"I think McDonald's has made itself vulnerable
in a certain way by its history of capitulating" to aboveground animal
rights groups like People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals, said
Martosko, whose organization represents restaurants and food
manufacturers.
PETA has embarrassed several fast-food chains
into altering their practices, but "McDonald's was really the first to
respond by saying, 'OK, we'll do things your way,'" Martosko said. "To my
mind, that sends a message to the entire social movement that you can be
pushed around here."
Factory farms, slaughterhouses and animal
research facilities all might be closer to animal cruelty, and all have
been targeted by animal rights groups.
But people identify far more with their local
McDonald's, said Gary Perlstein, a professor emeritus at Oregon's Portland
State University and board member of the watchdog group Stop
Eco-Violence.
"A terrorist group is always going to attack
the symbol," Perlstein said. "McDonald's will be a target until they only
sell vegetable sandwiches."
ALF and ELF are closely affiliated and brag
about their attacks through aboveground intermediaries like Coronado. Yet
the groups frustrate investigators who say they have no structure,
operating in anonymous cells that commit copycat crimes and then
disappear.
Two weeks before the Chico attacks, Coronado
appeared at a conference for radical activists at California State
University, Fresno, 230 miles south of Chico.
He now divides his time between Tucson, Ariz.,
and Northern California, and plans to be back in Fresno next week giving a
seminar to prospective tree-sitters who want to protest logging by Pacific
Lumber Co. along California's North Coast. His involvement in those
protests has enabled Pacific Lumber to suggest the pacifist protesters
there are allied with ecoterrorists.
While Coronado encouraged property damage
aimed at corporations, he emphasized ALF's and ELF's credo of avoiding
injuries or death to humans or animals. He denounced as aberrations recent
violent statements by ELF and former ELF spokesman Craig Rosebraugh that
law enforcement officials fear may signal a change in the group's
philosophy.
"We as a movement are brought up to be
nonviolent," Coronado said. "We know the repression that awaits people who
use physical violence."
Regardless of intent, law enforcement
officials said it's only a matter of time before someone is hurt or
killed, perhaps fighting one of the groups' arson
fires.
Yet the groups' distinction between damaging
property and harming people has helped make them successful, particularly
in university environments where they flourish, said
Perlstein.
"Because a lot of people agree with the goal -
the protection of animals - they have a hard time agreeing that the
activities of ALF or ELF are terrorism," Perlstein said. "They just refuse
to put the same label on this as they do
al-Qaida."