In public statements, two of the defendants expressed
their regret for crimes they now consider misguided deeds done out of deep
devotion to environmental causes.
The four are among 13 defendants in "Operation Backfire,"
the name investigators gave to their effort to solve a score of arsons over
five years in six states that did an estimated $30 million in damage. Most of
the arsons were claimed by the shadowy Environmental Liberation Front and
Animal Liberation Front.
With Thursday's court action, all defendants have pleaded
guilty except three who remain fugitives and are believed to be out of the
country.
Under the plea deals, three of the defendants - Daniel
Gerard McGowan, 32; Nathan Fraser Block, 25; and Joyanna Zacher, 28 - may get
eight-year prison terms. The fourth, Jonathan Christopher Mark Paul, 40, may
get a five-year term. All are free to argue for shorter terms at their
sentencing hearings, which have not yet been scheduled.
McGowan admitted taking part in 2001 fires at the Superior
Lumber Co. in Glendale and at Jefferson Poplar Farm in Clatskanie. Block and
Zacher admitted their roles in 2001 in burning 35 vehicles at the former Joe
Romania Chevrolet Truck Center in Eugene and in the fire at Jefferson Poplar
Farm.
Paul admitted helping to destroy the Cavel West Horse
Meatpacking plant in Redmond in 1997.
Thursday's plea deals, unlike the six earlier ones, do not
require the defendants to testify against each other or against other
co-conspirators - a condition the four defendants demanded in a joint
settlement offer made to the government.
Assistant U.S. Attorney Kirk Engdall said the government
accepted the no-testimony proposal in order to settle the case. But the
defendants' demand carried a price. The government is recommending the four get
proportionately longer sentences than the six co-defendants who agreed to
cooperate fully, he said.
While the case is all but over, more arrests are possible,
Engdall said.
"We believe we have basically disassembled the Northwest
cell of ELF/ALF arsonists," Engdall said. "There may be other arrests."
Within moments of the guilty pleas in Eugene, U.S.
Attorney Karin Immergut led seven other local, state and federal
law-enforcement officials into a press conference in Portland's federal
courthouse.
Immergut praised the hard work and cooperation of the FBI;
Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives; Eugene Police; Lane County
sheriff's office; Bureau of Land Management; U.S. Forest Service; Oregon State
Police and the state Department of Justice.
"They were relentless, persistent, thorough and dogged,"
she said. "They got the job done."
Immergut called the four guilty pleas the conclusion of
"the largest case of domestic terrorism in United States history," later
amending that to say it was the largest case of eco-terrorism.
Environmental activists have criticized the use of the
"terrorism" label against perpetrators of property crimes, saying the label
unfairly taints the legal efforts of legitimate activist groups and government
dissidents. U.S. District Judge Ann Aiken will decide whether to apply harsher
sentences under the federal terrorism statute when the defendants are
sentenced.
Robert Jordan, the FBI's special agent in charge in
Oregon, said the conspirators deserve the punishment awaiting them.
"They spent year after year using violence to try and
intimidate you and your government into their twisted way of thinking," Jordan
said. "Instead of using reason and logic, they used fire bombs and destruction.
Instead of using peaceful, lawful methods, they used fear and threats."
Jordan said investigators continue to search for the
fugitive conspirators. They believe Joseph Dibee, 38, is in Syria, where he had
relatives. Another fugitive, Josephine Sunshine Overaker, 31, may be in Europe.
Rebecca Rubin, 32, may be in her native Canada, Jordan said.
Jordan disputed a reporter's assertion that it took a long
time to solve the case. He noted how the cell took extreme measures to avoid
leaving behind any DNA or fingerprint evidence. He also noted their deep
commitment to secrecy.
During Thursday's hearing, McGowan told Aiken he stopped
doing arson after two attacks because he realized it did not create a better
world. He apologized for the property loss, disruption and danger he caused to
firefighters.
"I hope that you will see that my actions were not those
of terrorist, but of a concerned young person who was deeply troubled by the
destruction of Oregon's beautiful old-growth forests and the dangers of
genetically modified trees," he said.
After the hearing, Alexandra Paul said her brother -
defendant Jonathan Paul - immediately recognized arson was wrong after he
participated in the Cavel West attack. She recounted his lifelong efforts to
fight the fur industry, to free laboratory animals, to thwart whale hunting and
to save ancient forests.
"Mr. Paul retains the hope that humans will embrace
environmental sustainability and renounce animal cruelty and exploitation," she
said. "He intends to continue to pursue those goals in an ethical and
transparent way."
OPERATION BACKFIRE:
The defendants and their
deals.
Stanislas Gregory Meyerhoff - 15 years, eight
months.
Kevin Tubbs - 14 years.
Chelsea Dawn Gerlach - 10
years.
Daniel Gerard McGowan - Eight years.
Nathan Fraser
Block - Eight years.
Joyanna Lynn Zacher - Eight years.
Suzanne Nicole Savoie - Five years, three months.
Kendall Tankersley
- Four years, three months.
Jonathan Paul - Four years, two
months.
Darren Todd Thurston - Three years, one month.
[Non-text portions of this
message have been removed]
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
NOTE: In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C.
section 107, any copyrighted material herein is distributed without profit or
payment to those who have expressed prior interest in receiving this
information for non-profit research and educational purposes only. For further
information please refer to:
http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtml